The video of this play can be found on the MLB Film Room (at 0:04). Ok, hear me out. Benintendi had 4 at-bats in this game: a single, a ground out, a fly out, and another single (the only other time he made contact was one foul ball but this does not involve him running). He does the position depicted on the card in both singles and the ground out. However, based on the official photo found on Getty Images, we can see that the catcher is in a relaxed, sitting position at the moment Benintendi is dropping the bat. In both singles, the catcher is either standing or about to stand. Even though the video doesn't exactly show the catcher or Benintendi at the moment the photo was taken, this has to be the play. Plus, it makes sense the catcher would be relaxed at this position as there are two outs, no one on base, and a clear ground ball.